Thursday, July 14, 2005

Indecision, Bias, and Overcoming Objections


Indecision on the part of a hiring manager, like Bias in a discussion at my job seeker group yesterday seems to fall under the general heading of 'Objections'. Indecision can often arise out of unspoken objections. Biases might be thought of as preconceived objections. Overcoming objections is a natural part of the selling process, so turn to what you've learned about salesmanship to find your answers.

Objections can fall along a dimension with Intrinsic characteristics on one end and Extrinsic factors on the other. Intrinsics are what you can't or won't change. Extrinsics are the opposite. Not having an MBA is an extrinsic and may be solved by going after an EMBA.

Intrinsics are generally the things left unstated: too old, too young, too white, too black. Of course having an MBA is something you can't really undo, so if being 'over-educated' is a beef for the hiring manager, it's an intrinsic.

Intrinsics can be minimized, maximized or reframed. If I'm 'over-educated' I can play it down or I can make my target market Higher Education, where it is valued.

Am I a 'diversity' candidate? I am Jewish and White and Male AND I grew up in multi-racial Cleveland Heights with children whose parents were everything from janitors to university professors. Cleveland itself is ethnically diverse and our family-owned grocery store introduced me to a number of cultures and the importance of customer service. Then I went to a university with many South American, Asian, and Middle Eastern students and started a career with General Electric, which was one of the more culturally diverse firms at that time.

My feeling is that an extrinsic is something you can act on or promise action on, even during that indecision period. And if I don't want to act on it, can I say I'm really going to be a good fit for the job? Will I have to change the organization's culture to what I feel is superior or am I going to synthesize from the best aspects of the organization and my own experiences?

Inexperience with the industry? "I've been reading the trade magazines, networking with ..., attended the ... seminar, and skimmed the classic .... Is it true that ...?".

Extrinsics can be turned back on the interviewer. "What do you recommend to strengthen my knowledge in the short term."

Of course there are only so many ways I can split my interests, and one reason I have so many technical books left unread at home is that I can't figure out whether to pursue Oracle, Java, and Banner or look further at Microsoft .Net, Business Objects, and some other major application.

My previous job search classes taught me to overcome each objection in turn and ask for the job each time the list of objections runs out. If the same objection keeps re-occurring, and I've exhausted my tactics for overcoming objections, it may simply be time to withdraw and move on. And withdrawing my candidacy is just one more tactic to overcoming an objection.

Copyright 2005 Harlan R. Cohen MBA,CPIM

Saturday, June 18, 2005

Stick a match to Redmatch?

My local chamber of commerce has found a vendor to support recruiters and job seekers in the community. Unfortunately, I don't share the same excitement they do. Here are some reasons:

Redmatch is not a technical marvel. I prefer DirectEmployers, Careerboard, Careerbuilder, and Cleveland.com. And Dice of course. See if you have the same problems I did. The areas below are the ones where I had difficulty or expected more. Your mileage will differ.... Results may not be typical....
  1. Location selection in geographic preferences is immature.
    • Page Up/Down does not work.
    • Cannot rapidly select an entire state.
    • Cannot rapidly select an entire country.
    • The convention of turning a checkbox off and on by tapping the space key is not implemented.
    • I tried to add 35 cities and received an error message without any prior warning that only 20 are allowed. I cancelled and added cities again as a consequence.
    • The wheel scroll did not work until I hovered over the down button on the vertical scroll bar. Then stopped again.
    • After selecting 18 cities I tried to save and it told me that only 20 are allowed. Someone neglected to reset the count variable in memory, apparently.
    • I gave up and proceeded on with just Cleveland as a city (prefilled by providing it in a previous screen.)
    • I returned to the My Job Preferences tab and selected more cities. When I saved the cities I received a message 'Save Successful' which erroneously used a warning icon, rather than a straightforward success icon.
  2. Employment History
    • Couldn't leave without saving an entry.
    • Entries are only dated by year.
  3. Education History
    • Asks for 'certifications' (diplomas or degrees) and makes no allowance for professional certifications.
    • Entries are undated.
  4. Resume Load
    • Following my resume browse and load of a Word.doc file, a warning box appeared for JavaScript Application' with an OK button and there was no warning text. Nature of the error is unknown.
    • Did not take the opportunity to load a picture.
    • After completing the wizard and returning to the My Resume tab I found that the resume had not loaded. I then saved the Word.doc file as Word.rtf and uploaded that. The header was dropped and some other formatting was interpreted differently than might be expected.
    • I attempted to Edit the resume using the action button and could only view the resume.
    • The resume entries were not transferred back into the Employment History and Education. This feature is available on a few job sites but its omission is not a negative.
  5. Profile Results
    • Ten matches in total from several major markets.
    • Because I expressed an interest in marketing (they don't have a fundraising/campaign category selection) and specified my industry as education, only four of the ten entries might be of interest, three of those went back to the end of April.
    • None were local.
    • Most of my entries came from The Job Network. The network is listed as a Redmatch product. The newspapers covered by the network should be found on this page http://www.thejobnetwork.com/statistics/members.asp?code=1 (I think you'll have to copy/paste into the browser). There are none listed for Ohio at this time.
  6. Search Results
    • I could finally specify 'ALL' cities but this gave me 1500 entries in the category Information Systems
    • 4Jobs.com seemed to be a major source of entries. I only sampled a few results pages however. It makes me think I should try 4jobs directly.
    • Restricting entries to Oracle also got me 1500 entries and they were Oracle entries. A few appeared to be duplicates.
    • There is no filtering on dates.
    • No sorting capabilities exist. Results are returned in roughly reverse chronology. Don't ask me what disrupts sequence. Revisions altering the date an entry was last modified?
    • I added a filter for only companies beginning with 'D'. The search had not returned results after five minutes and I closed down the browser.
  7. Job agents or Saved Searches
    • None that I could tell.




Copyright 2005 Harlan R. Cohen MBA,CPIM

Friday, May 13, 2005

Government Budgets vs. Local Interests

"Cleveland will lose 1,013 high-paying civilian jobs and 15 military positions at the Defense Finance and Accounting Services Office in a realignment announced by the Defense Department today." according to The Plain Dealer / Associated Press report.

Isn't it past time that the Congress insist a local area have its federal employment frozen when the local area is still suffering from a recession? And let's not pretend that the moment a recession turns around is the time for layoffs or facility closings. Every three months in a recession should represent two to four months of protection following the turnaround.

Now I can see where all bets may be off during a national recession. However the political parties that favor getting the 'welfare class' into jobs so they can take support directly from the economy, these politicians ought to understand the concept of maintaining job enrollments to spur an economy during difficult economic times.

Voinovich, DeWine, Taft, Campbell, Hagan, DiMora, LaTourette, Tubbs-Jones, Kucinich. Are you listening?



Copyright 2005 Harlan R. Cohen MBA,CPIM